Argumentation – I1

I1 Argumentation

Scope note:

This class comprises the activity of making honest inferences or observations. An honest inference or observation is one in which the E39 Actor carrying out the I1 Argumentation justifies and believes that the I6 Belief Value associated with resulting I2 Belief about the I4 Proposition Set is the correct value at the time that the activity was undertaken and that any I3 Inference Logic or methodology was correctly applied.

Only one instance of E39 Actor may carry out an instance of I1 Argumentation, though the E39 Actor may, of course, be an instance of E74 Group.

Examples:

My classification and dating of this bowl (I5)

My adoption of the belief that Dragendorff type 29 bowls are from the 1st Century AD (I7)

In First Order Logic:

  • I1(x) ⊃ E13(x)

Outgoing properties:

Scope Notes

Show Scope note Language Namespace View details Comments

Examples

Show Example Language Namespace View details Comments
My classification and dating of this bowl (I5) en WIP 0
My adoption of the belief that Dragendorff type 29 bowls are from the 1st Century AD (I7) en WIP 0

Additional notes

Show Notes Language Namespace View details Comments

Identifier : I1

Labels

Label Language Last updated View details Comments
Argumentation * en 2019-01-23 0

* : Standard label for this language

Namespace

Namespace Last updated
CRMinf version 0.7 2019-12-04

Parent classes

Class Justification Root namespace View association
E13 Attribute Assignment CIDOC CRM

Ancestor classes

Class Depth Root namespace
E1 CRM Entity 6 CIDOC CRM
E1 CRM Entity 7 CIDOC CRM
E2 Temporal Entity 5 CIDOC CRM
E4 Period 4 CIDOC CRM
E5 Event 3 CIDOC CRM
E7 Activity 2 CIDOC CRM
E92 Spacetime Volume 5 CIDOC CRM
E92 Spacetime Volume 6 CIDOC CRM
Thing 7 The OWL 2 Schema vocabulary
Thing 8 The OWL 2 Schema vocabulary
SP1 Phenomenal Spacetime Volume 5 CRMgeo: a Spatiotemporal Model
Feature 6 GeoSPARQL
SpatialObject 7 GeoSPARQL
S15 Observable Entity 6 CRMsci: An Extension of CIDOC CRM to support scientific observation

Childs and descendant classes

Class identifier Depth Root namespace
S3 Measurement by Sampling 3 CRMsci: An Extension of CIDOC CRM to support scientific observation
S4 Observation 1 CRMsci: An Extension of CIDOC CRM to support scientific observation
S5 Inference Making 1 CRMsci: An Extension of CIDOC CRM to support scientific observation
S6 Data Evaluation 2 CRMsci: An Extension of CIDOC CRM to support scientific observation
S7 Simulation or Prediction 2 CRMsci: An Extension of CIDOC CRM to support scientific observation
S8 Categorical Hypothesis Building 2 CRMsci: An Extension of CIDOC CRM to support scientific observation
S19 Encounter Event 2 CRMsci: An Extension of CIDOC CRM to support scientific observation
S21 Measurement 2 CRMsci: An Extension of CIDOC CRM to support scientific observation
A1 Excavation Process Unit 2 CRMarchaeo: An Extension of CIDOC CRM to support the archaeological excavation process
A6 Group Declaration Event 2 CRMarchaeo: An Extension of CIDOC CRM to support the archaeological excavation process
A9 Archaeological Excavation 2 CRMarchaeo: An Extension of CIDOC CRM to support the archaeological excavation process
I5 Inference Making 1 CRMinf: An Extension of CIDOC-CRM to support argumentation
I7 Belief Adoption 1 CRMinf: An Extension of CIDOC-CRM to support argumentation

Related classes

Relation Class Justification Defined in namespace View details

Outgoing properties (this class is domain)

Domain Property identifier Range Namespace
I1 Argumentation J2 conclued that I2 Belief CRMinf version 0.7

Outgoing properties (inherited from ancestors)

Domain Property identifier Range Namespace
I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) P1 is identified by E41 Appellation CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) P2 has type E55 Type CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) P3 has note E62 String CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) P48 has preferred identifier E42 Identifier CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) P137 exemplifies E55 Type CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) L47 has comment E62 String CRMdig version 3.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) L4 has preferred label E62 String CRMdig version 3.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) L53 is not uniquely identified by E62 String CRMdig version 3.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) geovP7 existence is deduced from geovC7 Data entity Geovistory ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) geovP12 same as E1 CRM Entity Geovistory ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) geovP13 derived from E1 CRM Entity Geovistory ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) histP31 time-independent entity association E1 CRM Entity CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) P4 has time-span E52 Time-Span CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) P114 is equal in time to E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) P115 finishes E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) P116 starts E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) P117 occurs during E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) P118 overlaps in time with E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) P119 meets in time with E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) P120 occurs before E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) histP1 involves E1 CRM Entity CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) histP29 is component of E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) histP30 has identity defining component E1 CRM Entity CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E4 Period) P7 took place at E53 Place CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E4 Period) P8 took place on or within E18 Physical Thing CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E4 Period) P9 consists of E4 Period CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E4 Period) Q1 occupied SP1 Phenomenal Spacetime Volume CRMgeo version 1.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) P11 had participant E39 Actor CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) P12 occurred in the presence of E77 Persistent Item CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) O13 triggers (is triggered by) E5 Event CRMsci version 1.2.3
I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) O14 initializes (is initialized by) S16 State CRMsci version 1.2.3
I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) histP18 has event type histC4 Event type CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) P14 carried out by E39 Actor CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) P15 was influenced by E1 CRM Entity CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) P16 used specific object E70 Thing CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) P17 was motivated by E1 CRM Entity CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) P19 was intended use of E71 Man-Made Thing CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) P20 had specific purpose E5 Event CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) P21 had general purpose E55 Type CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) P32 used general technique E55 Type CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) P33 used specific technique E29 Design or Procedure CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) P125 used object of type E55 Type CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) P134 continued E7 Activity CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) socP3 realized (duplicate, delete) socE2 Activity Plan CRMsoc version 0.1 ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) L29 has responsible organization E40 Legal Body CRMdig version 3.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) L30 has operator E21 Person CRMdig version 3.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) L34 has contractor E40 Legal Body CRMdig version 3.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) L35 has commissioner E40 Legal Body CRMdig version 3.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) socP15 realised (was realised by) socE2 Activity Plan CRMsoc version 0.1 ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) readP8 has frequency R18 Frequency READ-IT ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) readP9 has intensity R17 Intensity READ-IT ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) has outcome readP20 R1 Outcomes READ-IT ongoing
I1 Argumentation (is a E13 Attribute Assignment) P140 assigned attribute to E1 CRM Entity CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E13 Attribute Assignment) P141 assigned E1 CRM Entity CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E92 Spacetime Volume) P10 falls within E92 Spacetime Volume CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E92 Spacetime Volume) P132 overlaps with E92 Spacetime Volume CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E92 Spacetime Volume) P133 is separated from E92 Spacetime Volume CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E92 Spacetime Volume) P160 has temporal projection E52 Time-Span CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a E92 Spacetime Volume) P161 has spatial projection E53 Place CIDOC CRM version 6.2
I1 Argumentation (is a SP1 Phenomenal Spacetime Volume) Q3 has temporal projection SP13 Phenomenal Time-Span CRMgeo version 1.2
I1 Argumentation (is a SP1 Phenomenal Spacetime Volume) Q4 has spatial projection SP2 Phenomenal Place CRMgeo version 1.2
I1 Argumentation (is a S15 Observable Entity) O12 has dimension (is dimension of) E54 Dimension CRMsci version 1.2.3

Incoming properties (this class is range)

Domain Property identifier Range Namespace

Incoming properties (inherited from ancestors)

Domain Property identifier Range Namespace
E1 CRM Entity geovP12 same as I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) Geovistory ongoing
E1 CRM Entity geovP13 derived from I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) Geovistory ongoing
E1 CRM Entity histP31 time-independent entity association I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
E2 Temporal Entity P114 is equal in time to I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E2 Temporal Entity P115 finishes I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E2 Temporal Entity P116 starts I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E2 Temporal Entity P117 occurs during I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E2 Temporal Entity P118 overlaps in time with I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E2 Temporal Entity P119 meets in time with I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E2 Temporal Entity P120 occurs before I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E2 Temporal Entity histP1 involves I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
E2 Temporal Entity histP29 is component of I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
E2 Temporal Entity histP30 has identity defining component I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
E4 Period P9 consists of I1 Argumentation (is a E4 Period) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E4 Period Q1 occupied I1 Argumentation (is a SP1 Phenomenal Spacetime Volume) CRMgeo version 1.2
E5 Event O13 triggers (is triggered by) I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) CRMsci version 1.2.3
E7 Activity P134 continued I1 Argumentation (is a E7 Activity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E7 Activity P15 was influenced by I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E7 Activity P17 was motivated by I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E7 Activity P20 had specific purpose I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E13 Attribute Assignment P140 assigned attribute to I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E13 Attribute Assignment P141 assigned I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E16 Measurement P39 measured I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E17 Type Assignment P41 classified I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E18 Physical Thing Q2 occupied I1 Argumentation (is a SP1 Phenomenal Spacetime Volume) CRMgeo version 1.2
E24 Physical Man-Made Thing P62 depicts I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E31 Document P70 documents I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E32 Authority Document P71 lists I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E36 Visual Item P138 represents I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E73 Information Object geovP2 mentions I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) Geovistory ongoing
E83 Type Creation P136 was based on I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E89 Propositional Object P129 is about I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E89 Propositional Object P67 refers to I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E92 Spacetime Volume P10 falls within I1 Argumentation (is a E92 Spacetime Volume) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E92 Spacetime Volume P132 overlaps with I1 Argumentation (is a E92 Spacetime Volume) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E92 Spacetime Volume P133 is separated from I1 Argumentation (is a E92 Spacetime Volume) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
E93 Presence P166 was a presence of I1 Argumentation (is a E92 Spacetime Volume) CIDOC CRM version 6.2
TyIn104 Présence objet_(être_l')_|_Présence I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) symogih.org ontology v.1.3 ongoing
histC1 Time-related Persistent Item Characteristic histP2 was initiated by I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
histC1 Time-related Persistent Item Characteristic histP3 was terminated by I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
histC2 Geographical localisation histP12 is location of I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
F29 Recording Event R20 recorded I1 Argumentation (is a E2 Temporal Entity) FRBRoo version 2.4
F35 Nomen Use Statement R38 refers to thema I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) FRBRoo version 2.4
F40 Identifier Assignment R45 assigned to I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) FRBRoo version 2.4
F51 Pursuit R59 had typical subject I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) FRBRoo version 2.4
F52 Name Use Activity R63 named I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) FRBRoo version 2.4
SP7 Declarative Spacetime Volume Q12 approximates I1 Argumentation (is a E92 Spacetime Volume) CRMgeo version 1.2
SP11 Temporal Reference System Q19 has reference event I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) CRMgeo version 1.2
histC10 Appellation for language histP9 isAppellationOf I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing
S4 Observation O16 observed value (value was observed by) I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CRMsci version 1.2.3
S4 Observation O8 observed (was observed by) I1 Argumentation (is a S15 Observable Entity) CRMsci version 1.2.3
S6 Data Evaluation O11 described (was described by) I1 Argumentation (is a S15 Observable Entity) CRMsci version 1.2.3
S21 Measurement O24 measured (was measured by) I1 Argumentation (is a S15 Observable Entity) CRMsci version 1.2.3
S22 Segment of Matter O23 is defined by (defines) I1 Argumentation (is a E92 Spacetime Volume) CRMsci version 1.2.3
geovC1 [Geovistory] Digital geovP11 refers to I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) Geovistory ongoing
D2 Digitization Process L60 documents I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CRMdig version 3.2
D29 Annotation Object L43 annotates I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) CRMdig version 3.2
socE3 Intention to Apply socP13 was initiated by (initiated) I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) CRMsoc version 0.1 ongoing
socE3 Intention to Apply socP14 was ended by (ended) I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) CRMsoc version 0.1 ongoing
geovC7 Data entity geovP8 corresponds to I1 Argumentation (is a E1 CRM Entity) Geovistory ongoing
histC25 Participation histP27 is participation in I1 Argumentation (is a E5 Event) CIDOC CRM Generic Extension for Historical Data Management and Interoperability, ongoing

Profiles using this class

Label Start date End date Last updated

Linked classes graph

Use mouse wheel to zoom in/out.

Comments